As everyone’s favorite Hallmark holiday rolls around we have been inspired by updating our neighborhood stores and finding conscious gifts that we think will score a home run for Valentines Day. We picked all sorts of categories and price ranges from very affordable to quite aspirational. We have gifts for him, her, they, us, everyone! They are artisanal, from small or heritage brands, sustainable, eco-friendly, unique, thoughtful and made for the conscious customer. Just click on the captions for a link to their online shop and more information.

We also will have a Galentines Day blog coming up with an idea we hope will catch on like wildfire. Stay tuned!

Below are our twelve picks (we had ten originally but just had to add two more gift suggestions).

THE TRIBES OF MOROCCO - MEDIUM ESSENCE OF ATLAS SERVING TAGINE

The Tribes of Morocco, a small store in the East Village that specializes in Moroccan products made by artisans have this beautiful tagine for serving Moroccan food. It comes in a blue and white Moroccan motif inspired by the Atlas Mountains that can equally serve as home decor. It’s the perfect gift for someone who loves to cook. Perhaps a tasty Moroccan meal can be included in the Valentine’s day gift?

MELA - MAKE A BAG

Mela - One of Mela’s bag style Luna in Zest color, $350

Mela is an up and coming award winning vegan handbag brand that not only shuns animal skin but also avoids using petroleum products which can be just as harmful to the environment in creating vegan products. Mela has created a material made from apple skins, an apple leather called Melatex®. We recommend not only the stylish handbags from Mela as a Valentines Day gift but offering their “Make a Mela Bag” an exclusive opportunity to design the Mela bag of your dreams at their Soho store. During your personalized consultation, you’ll explore their range of styles, select your details, and watch your vision come to life through their made-to-order process. In two weeks, your custom creation will be ready to take home! Carefully crafted and sustainably made. If there is no access to the New York store you can always order one of their styles online. To make an appointment click here.

THE CANVAS - AZURE BEADED EARRINGS

The Canvas is a multibrand fashion and design retailer bringing a selection of brands to New York City. The brands are emerging or established, each characterized by the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. We wanted to recommend a gift from The Canvas and these stunning beaded earrings are a statement piece of jewelry anyone would love for Valentines Day. Handmade by a women’s collective in Mexico, these earrings are a Gold/Silver plated earrings, composed of an assembly of colored beads woven by hand. Approx. 5.25”L x 1”W - 13.5cm x 3cm. Best is that it is a very affordable piece of jewelry.

WICKED AND POUR - CANDLE MAKING CLASSES

Wick and Pour - Candle Making Classes - From $50

A great idea for Valentines Day is to have an experience together creating a beautiful souvenir of the day and that is Wick and Pour, a candle making shop in New York City. Here you and yours can create your signature scent, use vibrant colors, and textures to craft candles that are uniquely yours. The candles are a combination of soy wax and their enticing scents are curated in-house with essential oils and phthalate-free fragrances. It’s a fun and easy experience, affordable and quite romantic.

COMMODITY - THE MINI WARDROBE SET

Commodity is a fragrance brand created by artisans using the best ingredients to create the most innovative scents. This is a sustainable, ethical fragrance brand that believes in transparency of what is in their scents using only clean ingredients which is a growing list of ingredients flagged by global regulatory bodies for potential health or environmental harm. Commodity partners exclusively with perfume houses that prioritize both environmental and social responsibility when sourcing raw materials from around the world and their packaging is more sustainable, as Commodity is working toward fully recyclable, reduced-impact packaging. We love their gifts sets especially “The Mini Wardrobe Set” which contains each fragrance in its best-selling Scent Space version (the container has three different settings a closely-projecting Personal, a noticeably unique Expressive, and a room-filling Bold version.) so that you can rotate your scent. Perfumes are such popular Valentines Day gifts and with this gift set that is unisex and convenient you can’t go wrong.

ONCEPT - TORONTO MEN’S RETRO SNEAKER

What’s a quick way to a man’s heart? A smart set of stylish trainers that are also sustainable. In comes Oncept, a brand that strives to have a low carbon footprint. Oncept has a process called “re-speckled” this is a process that uses leftover rubber from other manufacturing and combines this excess material with new rubber to produce new outsoles. Re-speckled is a certified process that uses 55% discarded material which saves hundreds of tons of waste in landfills. They utilize sustainable bio based memory foam made from castor oil (plant based) and recycled rubber. They source their leather ethically and use recycled nylon (made from plastic water bottle) and other recycled materials. That said the brand does not skim on style. Toronto mixes retro style, comfortability and eco-friendly design (seen here in Flame, offered in five color ways). It’s definitely a win/win gift for everyone.

THE MEADOW - CLOUDFATHER VALENTINA DARK CHOCOLATE WITH MAPLE

The Meadow - Cloudforest - Valentina Dark Chocolate with Maple - $12

The Meadow is a much loved neighborhood shop selling pantry goods such as salts, bitters, chocolates and more (plus fresh cut flowers). Since chocolates are an iconic Valentines Day gift for your loved one we have chosen for our chocolate gift a chocolate from the chocolate brand cloudforest, a small Portland, Oregon based chocolatier that uses organic ingredients with unique flavors. Valentina is the flavor we chose that is 75% dark chocolate with a combination of Canadian maple and Ecuadorian cacao (weight: 1.2345 oz). It’s a delicious and affordable gift.

THEO HABERDASHERY - ROLEX MARCONI SPECIAL WATCH FROM THE 1940’S

Theo’s Haberdashery - Rolex Marconi Special Watch from the 1940”s - $1,250

One of the most sustainable and conscious gifts you can give your loved one are vintage pieces. Whether it’s fashion, accessories, art, home decor, objects or jewelry, to find a special piece that has been created by an artisan and was once treasured. Theo’s Haberdashery is a men’s boutique curated to showcase vintage Americana, fine watches and jewelry, and includes their very own cigar line inspired by their namesake Theodore Roosevelt. An exceptional gift for a man is a piece of jewelry and a vintage Rolex is the ultimate gift for your loved one. We love this one-of-a-kind piece for the boutique, a Rolex Marconi Special Watch from the 1940’s. It’s 28mm with a Ghost sector dial, Mechanical wind. In working condition. The watch comes with a one year mechanical warranty. It’s on the high end of spending for a gift but we feel it will be cherished and destined to become a family heirloom.

SPIRITED AWAY - RITUAL ZERO PROOF - TEQUILA ALTERNATIVE

Spirited Away - Ritual Zero Proof - Alternative Tequila - $35

Sharing a Valentines Day cocktail is a romantic way to start an evening or Valentines Day meal. However many people these days are forgoing alcohol yet miss the taste and the social bonding of having a cocktail to toast their love. That is why we highly recommend from our favorite alcohol-free wine and spirits store, Spirited Away this zero proof tequila alternative, Ritual Zero. “Crafted for margaritas, Ritual Tequila Alternative brings the heat to your favorite cocktails. Greeting you with a rich golden hue, a traditional blue agave aroma opens up on the pour. Ripe tropical guava is underscored by the mellow spice of black peppercorn as the flavor grows, going deeper with charred oak and mesquite smoke. Bright Mexican lime gives way to a clean, spicy finish, with a kiss of cracked sea salt for good measure.” Ritual’s tequila alternative has a high taste score of 94 points from the industry-standard Beverage Testing Institute. It’s all the taste and ceremony of tequila without the hangover and poor decision making tequila can incur (speaking from experience).

TORU + NAOKO - CARMIN BODYSUIT

It wouldn’t be a Valentines Day gift guide without recommending lingerie. We have chosen a gorgeous piece from the sustainable lingerie brand Toru + Naoko. Toru + Naoko is “dedicated to crafting beautiful lingerie with a conscience. Their 100% female artisan team ensures ethical production, while they source sustainable materials and operate in small batches to eliminate waste. Eco-friendly packaging and carbon offsetting initiatives further our commitment to a greener future.” The Carmin Bodysuit features a high waist bottom thong, attached in the front center with a bralette, with adjustable back and shoulder straps. Also includes a pair of detachable straps that can be attached to the front center. It’s beautiful, sexy, stylish and just keeps on giving and giving. She’ll love this lingerie and will want to wear it daily, you know for the sustainability. ;)

IRVING GREEN - FOXFORD MAEVE CASHMERE & wool THROW

If your perfect idea of celebrating Valentines Day is staying in with your bo having a Netflix and chill kinda evening then may we recommend this exquisite cashmere and wool throw. Just imaging cuddling under this ultra soft cashmere and wool throw from Irving Green, a boutique that curates home decor and gifts from around the world. This cashmere and wool throw, the Maeve, comes from Foxford Mill, a mill that sits on the banks of the River Moy in County Mayo, Ireland. They have been manufacturing the finest wool throws and blankets for over 130 years. The Maeve is woven in a classic herringbone design, and crafted from a soft blend of lambswool and cashmere with a traditional roll fringe. Material: 95% Lambswool 5% Cashmere. Size : 140 x 180cm. Perfect for a cozy night in celebrating Valentines Day.

SANTA MARIA NOVELLA - EMULSIONE ANALCOLICA NON-ALCOHOLIC AFTER SHAVE EMULSION

A gift he is bound to love and appreciate is from the Florence heritage brand Santa Maria Novella, the Emulsione Analcolica Non-Alcoholic After Shave Emulsion. It’s not only women that should have a skin routine, help guide him to the amazing products from Santa Maria Novella, the after shave emulsion has no alcohol and is an “innovative and gentle formula with citrus notes, designed for those seeking an effective post-shave treatment that is also kind to the skin. This milky fluid emulsion boasts astringent, emollient, and refreshing properties, offering an immediate sensation of freshness after both electric and razor.” This emulsion will get the skin hydrated, healthy and smelling light and clean. A skin care routine is a sign of self care and self love and isn’t that what Valentines Day is all about, Hallmark holiday and all?

Well that is our selection for conscious gift giving on Valentines Day. We hope the selection helps you out or at the very least gives you a guideline to find conscious gifts that are local from a small, artisanal business. If you are going to celebrate Valentine's Day remember it really is the thought that counts. Happy Valentines Day!

By Natalie Rivera

Mela

A VERY CONSCIOUS VALENTINES DAY GIFT GUIDE - 2026